Did Dave Portnoy Underrate This Seaside Heights, NJ Pizza Staple?

Love him or hate him, when Dave Portnoy is spotted in Jersey doing a pizza review, our ears generally perk up when he gives out a rating on our local pizza spots.

And Dave Portnoy just reviewed one of the Jersey Shore's most legendary pizza places, and his score is leaving some people shocked.

Get our free mobile app

Was This Really Dave Portnoy's First Time At The Jersey Shore?

Now, according to Dave Portnoy, this was his first time at the Jersey Shore; however, it's not really his first time near the Jersey Shore.

He was spotted giving a review to Pacidough's Pizza off Atlantic City Boulevard in Toms River a few months ago.

More on that here.

READ MORE: 6 NJ Beaches Closed To Swimming Due To Bacteria

Dave Portnoy's First Boardwalk Pizza Review Hits Seaside Heights, NJ

So Dave's reviewed Jersey Shore pizza before; this was just his first time reviewing boardwalk pizza.

Which lives in a league of its own.

What Pizza Seaside Heights, NJ Pizza Place Did Dave Portnoy Review?

READ MORE: Corn Topped Pizza? It's A Thing In Asbury Park, NJ

So, what boardwalk pizza place did Dave Portnoy give a review to? He was spotted in Seaside Heights, so he has some options.

I would have loved to see what he has to say about Sawmill Pizza, or even Marathon Pizza, which is my personal favorite spot for a slice at the Shore.

Dave Portnoy Reviews Maruca's Tomato Pies In Seaside Heights, NJ

But Dave Portnoy's most recent One Bite Challenge takes place at the legendary Maruca's Tomato Pies.

Maruca's may be one of the most iconic pizza shops in Seaside, being featured in shows like Man Versus Food, and it's a hot spot for tourists and locals alike.

What Score Did Dave Portnoy Give Maruca’s Tomato Pies?

So what did Dave Portnoy think of Maruca's Tomato Pies?

Personally, I think he robbed them. Maruca's should be at least 8.5, especially if you get it hot out of the oven.

So, if Dave Portnoy were to review another Boardwalk Pizza Shop, where would you want to see him review?