NJ's 5 Quirkiest Coffee Shops That Locals Swear By

New Jersey is a coffee lover's dream. We have so many different fun, unique, and quirky shops that there's something for everyone. Whether you're just looking for a simple, slow drip decaf to enjoy in the afternoon or you want something chock-full of caffeine to give you that morning boost, Jersey has you covered.

What's awesome about Jersey, too, is that we have a ton of local coffee shops that offer fun and unique vibes. In Toms River alone, we have Spire Coffee, Caffeine Haven, and First Date Coffee. Each one offers something a little different, but one thing is consistent: they all have great coffee.

New Jersey Is Filled With Weird, And Unique Coffee Shops

But if you're looking for a real coffee experience, there are 5 New Jersey coffee shops you have to check out just for the experience. These places are more than just a spot to grab a hot cup of joe; they offer you a fun experience while you grab a cup.

The 5 Weirdest Coffee Shops In NJ You Have To Check Out

Get our free mobile app

According to TikTok user Revciancio, these are NJ's 5 weirdest coffee shops you have to check out.

1. Catfight Coffee

Located on Main Street in Boonton, Catfight Coffee brings punk rock vibes to your coffee, featuring blends like Misfits Crimson Roast, Alice Cooper single origin, and Creepshow Pistachio Birthday Cake.

2. Grovers Mill Coffee Company

Photo Credit: Google Maps

Remember when a radio broadcast had everyone thinking that aliens were invading? Grovers Mill Coffee Company is a War of the Worlds-inspired coffee shop that not only serves up hot cups of coffee, but also features a little museum that pays homage to the legendary broadcast.

3. Nightshade Coffee

It's a goth-inspired coffee shop in Westwood and is one of the newest additions to Jersey's coffee scene.

Nightshade features a hauntingly elegant atmosphere that'll make you want to break out the trip pants, goth make-up, and grab a cup of joe.

4. Paper Plane Coffee Company

Get our free mobile app

This place is so cool. Paper Plane Coffee Company is located in Montclair and is a plane-themed coffee shop. There's even a wall that's decorated like the aisle of a plane, so you can feel like you're drinking your coffee at 30 thousand feet.

5. Catfe Montclaire

No, it's not a typo. Catfe Montclaire is a cat adoption center that also serves up some coffee brews while you hang out with adoptable cats that you can take home!

What's your favorite place in Jersey to grab a cup of coffee? These are some of our favorite spots.

Here’s 40 great NJ coffee spots to visit

New Jerseyans have a strong crop of choices for a freshly roasted cup of coffee, around NJ. Here's a roundup of 40 spots to get caffeinated — some of them different locations for the same NJ-born brand.

Gallery Credit: Erin Vogt